Continuing from last week, there are a few other things I’ve been thinking about regarding Star Wars VII.
As people have mentioned, there are a lot of similarities between Episode VII and Episode IV. I think a lot of these similarities come from both movies fulfilling the same phase of the Campbellian cycle—the point where the hero is identified, the call to adventure is given, the call is rejected, and the call is eventually accepted. Likewise, in this phase, the mentors, helpers, and villains of the cycle are introduced. So, they certainly fill the same function, in that respect. However, I think the two movies are used for different purposes, despite their similarities. A New Hope is, in addition to its Campbellian role, an introduction to the world and the story. It starts in the middle, but it really brings viewers into the world Lucas has created. On the other hand, The Force Awakens serves as a bridge, connecting the original trilogy and (chronologically) second incarnation of the cycle to the third trilogy/cycle. And there is where we see the homages to IV-VI, creating the links between different iterations of the Campbellian cycle.
The other thing that came to mind is objects. This could be due to my recent reading of Patrick Geary’s Furta Sacra, but the questions of Luke’s lightsaber (given to Reye) and Vader’s helmet keep coming to mind. Obvious questions about how Luke’s saber reappeared arise, given that the saber discussed is Luke’s first (and Anakin’s), the one lost on Bespin.
I, perhaps because of Geary, started thinking about these objects as something akin to religious relics. On one hand, the lightsaber could be a fake, from some random pre-Empire Jedi or a fleeing Jedi who sold it off for passage out of the Empire’s sphere of power. However, these explanations don’t fit the epic tone or story. Rather, my practical side suggests it fell into a shaft like Luke did and some Bespin maintenance ugnaught picked it up and sold it. Taken in the context of relics, though, the saber must be saved and returned for worship.
Likewise, Vader’s helmet needs to be recovered from the Endor pyre, either by Luke (as a reminder of what could be) or by Ren as a relic of worship. It takes on a powerful symbolic role, and received devotion on the part of whoever recovered it.
Alternately, Luke’s lightsaber could be seen as fulfilling the role of magic swords throughout Earth’s legends. In this way, it could be a sort of unnamed Durendal or Excalibur, the symbol of the Chosen One or the “True Hero” (moving from Anakin to Luke to Reye as appropriate). There is certainly a counter argument regarding Anakin, unless we recall that he gave up that particular saber/sword when he joined Palaptine, thus becoming the villain and rejecting his role as a hero of the Clone Wars. It then must pass to Luke, the hero of the Rebellion, “destined” to rebuild the Jedi Order. Then to Reye, the one who appears set to combat the villain Luke accidentally created (much as Luke defeated the villain that his own mentor, Kenobi, accidentally created).